SubjectNest · Year 3 Science · Term 1 · Weeks 09–10 · sequence Days 41–50

N19 · Museum-caption reader choice

Child invitation

Give the garden reader a source-qualified plan message and an open user question.

Four teacher moves

Guided different complete source

Different fictional garden-exhibit reader needs to distinguish a plan from a planted bed. CaptionM says “planting plan”; N says “plants grew” although only a plan exists. Invite a useful message/clue/actual-reader limit.

Id

N19

Mode limit

These are supported teaching opportunities after component review. Reasoning from a supplied account, a model and actual child conduct are different evidence. A helper operation is attributed; declining, length or format is not an ability diagnosis or grade.

Next decision

If this distinction is still unclear, return to one source-labelled heading pair in this new account and one question. If clear, offer a genuinely fresh ordinary job after further learning. Do not rehearse the held key and call its repetition untouched first/later evidence.

Observable evidence

Child makes a purposeful source-bounded message and retains untried reader use.

Ordinary staff possible model

P has a truthful clue useful for that job; no actual visitor success is supplied.

Teacher preparation

Read the complete new source and different guided account below; prepare large paper headings and a genuinely empty own response area. The accounts are original supplied fiction, not a verified local event. Offer spoken/signed/AAC, pointing with confirmed read-back, drawing or verbatim scribing. No specialised equipment, media recording, purchases or public sharing is needed.

Title

Museum-caption reader choice

Whole unrelated source

Fictional museum reader needs to distinguish a model from a real object. CaptionP says “paper model, size not measured”; Q says “exact object size” despite no size record. No actual visitor trial exists.